Toggle Navigation
Toggle Navigation
Toggle Navigation
The Board’s Guide to Succession Planning

The Board’s Guide to Succession Planning

< Back to Blog

As the saying goes, “All good things must come to an end.” And that means even the most successful nonprofit leaders will eventually move on.

For nonprofit boards, finding and hiring a new executive leader can feel daunting. After all, it’s one of the most important responsibilities a board will face, and the stakes are high.

But leadership transitions don’t have to throw your organization into turmoil. With deliberate planning and preparation, your board can approach a transition with confidence.

The key is to start long before a departure is on the horizon.

Why Succession Planning Matters

According to BoardSource’s Leading With Intent report (2021), only 29% of nonprofits surveyed had a written succession plan in place.

If your organization is among the 71% without a written plan, don’t panic. You don’t need to have everything figured out overnight. Taking small, intentional steps now can help protect your organization, preserve organizational knowledge, and ensure stability during a leadership transition.

Without a plan, nonprofits can face difficult challenges. Long-serving executives often hold valuable information and relationships that are hard to replace. Key donors may take a “wait and see” approach before committing additional funding, while staff and board members may struggle to navigate uncertainty about the organization’s future.

Funders are paying attention, too. Foundations and grantmakers recognize that leadership transitions can affect an organization’s long-term sustainability. Having a succession plan shows your nonprofit is thinking ahead and taking steps to protect its mission.

Ultimately, succession planning isn’t about preparing for someone to leave. It’s about making sure the organization is positioned to thrive, no matter who is leading it.

Where Should I Begin and Who Is Responsible?

If you serve on a nonprofit board and aren’t sure whether your organization has a succession plan, start by asking!

Succession planning is a board responsibility. Just as boards are responsible for financial oversight and strategic direction, they must also ensure the organization is prepared for changes in executive leadership. 

The board chair, working alongside the executive committee, should help make succession planning an ongoing priority. When a leadership transition occurs, the board oversees the transition process and makes the final hiring decision. Depending on the organization’s size and structure, forming a dedicated search committee may also make sense.

But what about the current CEO or executive director? Should they be involved? Absolutely!

While the board owns the process, current leadership plays an important role in preparing the organization for the future. That includes documenting essential processes, sharing institutional knowledge, maintaining key relationships, and developing internal leadership capacity.

With a plan in place, no one is left rushing to locate critical documents, identify key contacts, or figure out how things get done. 

And when the time does come for a leadership change, the board can focus on supporting both the outgoing and incoming leaders, helping ensure a smoother transition for everyone.

Steps to Prepare for a Leadership Transition

Whether your organization is anticipating a departure or simply preparing for the unexpected, here are five steps your board can take now. 

  1. Make succession planning a regular priority. Don’t wait until your executive leader announces a departure to begin the conversation. Revisit your succession plan periodically, just as you would your strategic plan or other important organizational documents.
  2. Assess your organization’s leadership needs. Think about where your nonprofit is headed, not just where it’s been. What skills, experience, and leadership traits will be most important in guiding the organization through its next chapter?
  3. Prepare for both planned and unexpected departures. Establish transition procedures for both emergent and planned scenarios, document essential processes and responsibilities, and identify potential interim leadership arrangements. Building internal leadership capacity can also help ensure continuity during a transition.
  4. Anticipate the costs of a transition. Executive searches may require significant time and financial resources. Evaluate possible expenses associated with recruiting, interim leadership, communications, and onboarding, and plan accordingly.
  5. Set your next leader up for success. The board’s responsibility doesn’t end when the hiring decision is made. Thoughtful onboarding, clear expectations, ongoing financial oversight, and consistent communication with staff and other key audiences can help a new executive leader build trust and gain momentum.

Is Your Organization Prepared?

Understanding where your organization stands is a great place to start. We created a checklist to help your board identify potential gaps and determine where to focus its efforts. Consider making it an agenda item at your next board meeting—review the checklist together to spark conversation and identify next steps.

With thoughtful preparation, your board can build confidence in its future and ensure the important work you’re doing today continues for years to come. 

About Kara: Kara Harrison serves as the Director of Capacity Building Services at Hedges. She previously held positions as the Community Investment and Grants Officer at a Community Foundation and as the Executive Director of a mental health-focused nonprofit. Kara is trained by BoardSource in Nonprofit Board Consulting and holds a Change Management Certificate from Cornell University. Her unique blend of hands-on experience and strategic insight allows her to connect with clients while guiding organizations toward operational excellence and impact.